When Leaders Fall

Few things are as taxing in an Elder’s life as when a fellow Leader falls into a sin which demands he step down from ministry and go through reconciliation and restoration. These areas include certain levels of moral failure, dishonesty and doctrinal error. A lot can be said on the qualifications of ‘certain levels,’ but that can be a post in and of itself.

There are many areas which we can discuss, but let’s look at two essential ones. One involves the fallen brother and the other the congregation or local body.


Purpose is to Restore – Should be obvious, but is easy to overlook and lose sight of this. The purpose is not punitive, but restorative. If our motive ever leaves this, we may perform the steps, but they will not produce life and liberty.

Open confession – Leader must be willing to go to any extinct, within the Scriptural mandate, to confess and repent to those harmed.

Accountability – Leader must submit to accountability to other Elders who are monitoring and tracking his healing and restoration process.

Counseling/Deliverance – Leader submits to periodic counseling meetings with Elders to work through to see and understand the root cause of the transgression and the path of victory.

Time of Restoration – Leader must submit to an undetermined time for restoration. This time, through much prayer and involvement, is defined by those working through and observing the Leader’s progress and freedom.


Thorough teaching on Restorative Church Discipline (RCD) – This is the source of most of the damage. Most congregations are very ignorant to the common NT practice of RCD. Then when it becomes necessary, they are overwhelmed at the process and take on a secular motive of punitive action, rather than restoration.

The Local Church’s Responsibility in RCD – In order for the congregation to stand within it’s responsibility, it must understand the forgiveness and healing of Christ to redeem lost men and to restore a fallen brother. Many times, the church has been guilty of ‘shooting the wounded.’

Focus of RCD – The focus must be upon the attempt to restore, not only the leader, but those damaged by his fall. This includes his friends, parishioners and more importantly, his family. Many times the family gets shunned or forgotten through the process and this is tragic.

Unity of RCD – The disciplinarian process is a work of spiritual unity among the local body. It is not just something the Elders do. Restoration must be a confirming, healing and restorative process for all involved. We are our brother’s keeper.


When properly exercised and performed, RCD will end with a wonderful celebration of rescuing a fallen brother to confident and liberating fellowship among the local church body. Because of the power of the Cross, we can participate in seeing and rejoicing with those restored and healed as wounded soldiers. Instead of shooting the wounded with the judgmental spirit of our times, let those of us who are believers display the loving and restoring hand of Jesus for all the world to see. The Lord has always used wounded men in ministry… and hallelujah, He still does!

People in the community may take note of all the decisions being made for Christ in our fellowship. However, they see the genuine spiritual maturity of our church when they observe how we respond to one who has fallen into sin. And when we rise above the hurt and pain of a fallen leader, through the grace and mercy of Christ, to seek his restoration, then we demonstrate the love of Jesus to all men. And, according to Jesus, this is how others know we are His disciples. (John 13:35)

“Brothers, if anyone is caught in any transgression, you who are spiritual should restore him in a spirit of gentleness. Keep watch on yourself, lest you too be tempted.” (Gal. 6:1, ESV)

Related topics:
The Three Jewels of Forgiveness
The Danger of Unforgiveness
God Uses the Wrong People

3 thoughts on “When Leaders Fall

  1. Good and sensitive post my brother. I love your heart for compassion for the fallen and integrity with regard to the Bible. As our own church was growing rapidly through many barriers I was often asked, “what is the secret to New Song’s growth?” My standard answer was “we pray and practice loving biblical church discipline.” God delights to bless a praying people who take his word, all of it, seriously.

    1. Thanks Marty. Amen to prayer and the serious response to God’s Word. The ‘saddest’ part of church discipline is when an erring brother refuses to biblically deal with his sin and forces the procedure to step four. (breaking fellowship) The most ‘sobering’ part is being in leadership and extending grace and restoration to a fellow brother, knowing we all fall short of God’s glory. The most ‘joyful’ part is the celebration of converting a brother from their error and seeing them rescued and healed. The most ‘profitable’ part is the knowledge of all the times church discipline never comes to public light because of the response of those who love the Lord and respond immediately. And the most ‘humbling’ part is the sense of unworthiness we feel to be one of the leaders who must carry the burden to carefully, prayerfully, and wisely carry out the procedures of restorative church discipline. Always reminds me of the verse, “My brethren, be not many masters, knowing that we shall receive the greater condemnation.” (Jas. 3:1)

  2. Pingback: Spiritual Warfare; Unanswered Prayer; Ed Stetzer; Herman Cain; and much more | ChosenRebel's Blog

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s