The Gifts of the Holy Spirit–Discernment or Rejection?

Holy Spirit, Not by mightEveryone seems to have an opinion about the gifts of the Holy Spirit. Christian publications, television, conferences and denominations are filled with thoughts, discussions and positions about them. There are usually two sides to this issue. On one side we have wild-eyed false prophets claiming to exercise the gifts while they manipulate and control gullible and ignorant believers. Then on the other side we have spiritually dry intellectuals holding conferences to proclaim that the Holy Spirit doesn’t operate like He did in the New Testament and teaching that all who claim to operate in gifts are under the power of Satan and are not genuine Christians. Wow…are those our only options?

It is easy to get into some dramatic and wild arguments about whether some of the gifts have “ceased” or whether all remain. Discussions about neuter nouns and modifiers in the Greek are all fascinating as men perform linguistic backflips in order to deny God’s gifts for today. (No one would read through the New Testament and arrive at the position that gifts have ceased. It only comes about with linguistic gymnastics by those scared of or predisposed against them.) Equally ridiculous are the silly presentations of the so-called ‘Word of Faith’ cronies making the gifts up under their own carnal desires rather than submitting to God’s Word. (No one would read through the Scriptures and conclude that the charlatans we see on religious TV are under the influence of the Holy Spirit. To do so only comes about through lack of discernment.)

LifeWay research did a survey a couple of years back asking Southern Baptist pastors, “Do you believe that the Holy Spirit gives some people the gift of a special language to pray to God privately?” 50 percent of SBC pastors said “Yes” and 43 percent said “No” while the rest responded “Don’t know.” This survey by Southern Baptists and with Southern Baptists makes it easy to see that this is a real issue for leaders and churches.

I believe the majority of conservative Southern Baptist pastors could bring much clarity and maturity to this issue, as they see the need for discernment instead of rejection. This is also true for many brothers in Christ I am around from various denominations, including Methodist, Wesleyan, Evangelical Free, Independent, and non-denominational churches. And this brings me to a couple of points I want to make.

The Cessationists (those who believe the gifts have ceased) don’t teach discernment, they teach rejection. Discernment is needed to navigate through the real and counterfeit. But, if one believes all gifts are false, we don’t have to use discernment. All that is left is to teach rejection of all supernatural manifestations and carry the danger of setting aside a genuine move of God. The Continuationists (those who believe the gifts are still available) fail to teach discernment also. Many times they embrace everything supernatural and do not teach about the counterfeit and false manifestations carried out by the enemy in the midst of the churches. While one camp embraces everything (even the foolish, insane, absurd and demonic), the other side rejects everything. (even the real and genuine) Is there a third option? Yes!

If we follow the explanations and restrictions the Apostle Paul laid out for the gifts (1Cor. 12-14), while recognizing that the Holy Spirit is here throughout the church age (Acts 2:17-21; Heb. 13:8), and that Satan counterfeits everything that is real from God (2Cor. 11:13-15), then we will see the need to embrace the biblical mandate of teaching and using discernment. (1Jn. 4:1; 1Thess. 5:21) Rejection of the gifts is not the biblical option–repentance for failure to use discernment is!

In a recent article from Desiring God ministries, John Piper, who believes the gifts are present until the return of Christ, said, “Charismatic doctrinal abuses, emotional abuses, discernment abuses, financial abuses, all have their mirror image in non-charismatic churches.” Of charismatics and non-charismatics alike, “we all stand under the word of God and we all need repentance.” *

Today, men either throw the baby out with the bathwater, say there is no baby in the bathwater, or keep the baby and drink the bathwater. We can do better! We can learn to use discernment as taught in the Scriptures, and keep the baby and insist on fresh bathwater. When we begin to reject the full ministry of the Holy Spirit in this age, we ask Him to abdicate His ministry, and that is a very dangerous position to take. When we fail to use discernment, we open the door for the counterfeits and deception of Satan. We can either have strange fire, no fire, or God’s fire!

Why are there fake revivals in America among many Charismatic groups? Because discernment is not used and the ‘fire is strange.’ Why are there no revivals among non-Charismatic groups? Because they are rejecting the agency and person of the Godhead that brings revival and there is ‘no fire.’ What will be an important element for a genuine revival? To use discernment and expect the God of the Scriptures to pour out the Holy Spirit afresh through our faith and repentance, and have God’s fire.

“Lord, we need a fresh outpouring of Your Spirit throughout the earth and upon Your children. Empower the church once again and protect us from foolishness by teaching us discernment. In Your Name and for Your glory we pray, amen.”

**For an in-depth teaching on the Christian’s responsibility to use discernment and the steps of how we are to do it, see my book, “Trying the Spirits.” It is available for Kindle and in paperback from

* Piper Addresses Strange Fire and Charismatic Chaos, “”

3 thoughts on “The Gifts of the Holy Spirit–Discernment or Rejection?

  1. Eliza

    The Holy Spirit works powerfully in the hearts of His beloved children. The other day I was starting to fuss about some trial in my life and the Holy Spirit of His accord brought Scripture to my mind to remind me of the truth. This brought about genuine rejoicing. Jesus said that we shall know the truth and the truth shall set us free. Your analysis of the situation is biblical and sound. We must rely upon the Holy Spirit in our walk with the Lord. That includes the gifts of the Spirit. Thank you for your godly post. God bless you:)

    1. PTLJ,that the Holy Spirit brings the scriptures.To us as we need them.In different situations.
      So refreshing to read your post.
      All in Jesus name

  2. Pingback: The Gifts of the Holy Spirit–Discernment or Rejection? | ChosenRebel's Blog

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s